| | |  | Keyword Search: Elton John | Home » The Nutcracker / Baryshnikov, Kirkland, Charmoli | | | | | | | Product Promotions: | | | | | Description: | | The Nutcracker marked the initial choreographic effort of Baryshnikov, universally hailed as one of the world’s greatest dancers. Under Baryshnikov’s inventive direction, the traditionally lighthearted story of a small girl’s dream on Christmas Eve is transformed into a more complex theatrical experience. Broadcast regularly on PBS, this American Ballet Theatre performance (directed in the studio by Tony Charmoli) stars Gelsey Kirkland as Clara and Mikhail Baryshnikov at the peak of his artistic ability as the Prince/Nutcracker. | | | Product Details: | | | Actors:
| Mikhail Baryshnikov, Gelsey Kirkland, Alexander Minz, Nanette Glushak, Gayle Young | | Director:
| Tony Charmoli | | Format:
| Classical, Color, DVD, NTSC | | Language:
| English | | Number of Discs:
| 1 | | Studio:
| Kultur Video | | Run Time:
| 78 minutes | | DVD Release Date:
| September 28, 2004 | | Average Customer Rating:
|  based on 88 reviews |
| | | | Customer Reviews: | |
Average Customer Review:
Write an online review and share your thoughts with other customers.
 A wonderful Nutcracker productionOct 29, 2009
I have seen many versions of the Nutcracker and this one really entertained me.
With Baryshnikov and Kirkland that should be no surprise, but over all it is a beautiful production.
The Nutcracker/Baryshnikov, Kirkland, CharmoliOct 19, 2009
I love that Nutcracker Ballet for perfect christmas season yearly. I first saw it since I was a kid. I never bore with it!
5 of 6 found the following review helpful:
 Make it a supplementary NutcrackerMay 07, 2009
The strengths of this Nutcracker can be summed up very simply: the dancing of Baryshnikov and Kirkland, which is to no one's surprise excellent and engaging. And there is some fine dancing from other members of the American Ballet Theater.
However, if you're looking for a Nutcracker that will cause you to revel in the holidays as well as Tchaikovsky's glorious music, this isn't it.
The sets by Boris Aronson range from a very ordinary parlor for Act 1 to a downright ugly fantasy candyland for Act 2. The costuming is second rate. The Chinese dancers don't look Chinese; the Russians don't look Russian. Other costuming seems cheap and uninspired. The general filming is too soft focus with not enough color contrast. And who's idea was it to have the ugly Act 2 thrones downstage blocking the action?
From a choreographic standpoint, this is also a disappointing production.
The children in Act 1 don't have much fun dancing and there are not enough of them. The adults don't act particularly well. It seems corners were cut in a lot of the dances in Act 2 which seem under populated and lacking in imagination and fire. You'd think the Russian dance in a Baryshnikov production would set your TV on fire; it is so tame and forgetable here. The Arabian dance is sadly missing altogether!
The idea of having Drosselmeyer appear in the climactic Act 2
pas de deux is a major distraction. He's simply out of place and adds no joy to the procedings. I'm sure this was meant as some deep psychological addition to the procedings, but it simply kills the moment and has nothing to do with the sublime music. And Act 2, which should end on a magical note, seems downright despressing in this production as Kirkland gazes out of a window like a lost soul???
If you want to revel in Nutcracker as a holiday treat, you must turn to the glorious Balanchine version with the NYC Ballet (on DVD) which has Christmas and joy written all over it. Sumptuosly designed, filmed and cast, it should be your first choice. The ABT version can only serve a supplementary version for a serious collection.
1 of 3 found the following review helpful:
 kept getting the wrong nutcracker videoMay 04, 2009
I ordered a specific Nutcracker ballet video: the one danced & choreographed by Mikhail Baryshnikov. Instead of the video, I ended up getting credit for the purchase, as two separate shipments of nutcracker videos were not the Baryshnikov version. But the seller DID reply promptly, did take action promptly and did issue credit promptly.
1 of 1 found the following review helpful:
MagicalJan 10, 2009
There are many beautiful version of The Nutcracker but this one is magical. Criticism of the production quality for its blue cast is correct - it's not nearly so colorful as, for example, the very recent San Francisco version. But what makes it magical is that these are not ballet stars showing their abilities. Baryshnikov and Kirkland and Minz ARE the Nutcracker/prince, Clara and Drosselmeyer. All the other performances I've watched are beautiful (save one) but the story seems to get lost in the dancing. Kirkland is beautiful, sad, excited, enchanting and vulnerable. Her dancing is effortless and she obviously is completely in character. Minz is Drosselmeyer - there can be no other like him. Baryshnikov sometimes seems a little over the top but the chemistry between him and Kirkland pulls him back every time. The choreography perfectly fits the music which perfectly fits the choreography. The end is perfect with Clara not wanting to wake and looking through the window like a little girl wishing.
All of that removes the blue cast for me and makes this performance one I look forward to every year. It IS a dream, after all and dreams like this one usually are softly focused. The performance invites you to join the dream.
But, as with strawberries and blueberries - it shouldn't be watched out of season or it will become ordinary. Watch the others for beautiful production values. Watch this one to live in that magic moment with Kirkland and Baryshnikov and Minz and all the others who dance and act and make music so wonderfully.
| | |
|
